Is your card still worth its annual fee? A ten-minute test
Count credits at what they really saved, count only the points beyond your next-best card, and decide in the month the fee posts. The test, worked through on one card for two households.
An annual fee is easy to justify on the day a card arrives, with the welcome bonus and a page of credits in view. A year later the question is different: did the card earn its fee in this household’s spending, at the prices this household actually pays? The test below takes about ten minutes, and works on any card with a fee.
The four-line test
Start with the fee
The number on the statement, including any fee for additional cards.
Credits, at what they were worth
Count a credit only for something that would have been bought anyway, and only at the amount that would have been spent. A $10 monthly credit used five times is worth $50, not $120.
The extra points, not all of them
Count only the points the card earned beyond what the next-best card in the wallet would have earned on the same spending, at a realistic value per point.
Perks that were used
Lounge visits, insurance claims or upgrades that happened, at what they would have cost otherwise. Perks that went unused count for nothing.
Counts
- Credits for purchases that would have happened anyway
- Points earned above the next-best card
- Benefits actually used this year
Doesn’t count
- The face value of credits that went unused
- Credits that only paid for something bought because of the credit
- Last year’s welcome bonus: it doesn’t come back
- Perks that sounded good and were never used
One card, two households

The Amex Gold makes a good example because its credits are easy to count. American Express advertises more than $500 a year in value, and the four dining and Uber credits alone add up to $424: up to $10 a month at a short list of dining partners including Grubhub and Five Guys, $10 a month in Uber Cash, up to $50 twice a year at Resy restaurants, and up to $7 a month at Dunkin’. Three need enrollment. The card earns 4 points per dollar at restaurants (up to $50,000 a year) and at U.S. supermarkets (up to $25,000 a year).
Two illustrations, with points valued at TPG’s 2.0¢ for Membership Rewards and compared with a card that earns 1 point per dollar:
Same card, same fee, opposite answers. The credits at face value would have said yes to both. The second household is close enough that one extra credit used each month would change the answer, which is the other half of the test: not only whether the card paid for itself, but whether next year will look any different.
Illustrations, not offers. Credits and earning rates as listed on the American Express Gold Card page; TPG values Membership Rewards points at 2.0¢. A household that redeems points for statement credits gets less per point.
Keep, change or close
Value well above the fee
Keep it
A comfortable margin, one that would survive a slower year, is a clear keep. A thin margin is worth a second look at next year’s plans before the fee posts again.
Most common answer
Value just under the fee
Ask about a different card
Ask the bank which other cards the account can move to. A lower-fee or no-fee card from the same bank, where it’s offered, usually keeps the account and its credit line open.
Before closing
Value well below the fee
Close it, carefully
Move or use the points first: some banks forfeit them the day the card closes. Then close it, knowing a smaller total credit line can nudge a credit score down for a while.
Points first
On that last point, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it plainly: part of a credit score depends on how much of the available credit is in use, so closing a card can raise that ratio and lower the score, sometimes only temporarily. It also lists a fee that outweighs a card’s benefits as a good reason to close one.
When to run it
The month the annual fee posts is the natural moment. Run the test on the past twelve statements, not on memory, and run it before the decision is made, not after the fee has been paid for another year.
The Atelier Take
A card earns its fee in a household’s own spending, not in the brochure. Count credits at what they really saved, count only the points beyond the next-best card, and decide in the month the fee posts. If the answer is no, ask about a different card before closing, and move the points first.
American Express and Gold Card are trademarks of American Express, used only to identify the card. Points Atelier is not affiliated with or endorsed by American Express.